I would like to see the Ravens win and think that they will be able to do so in a highly offensive game, 35-31. I think Joe Flacco, Ray Rice, Torry Smith, Michael Oher, and coach John Harbaugh are all class acts. It’s not that there aren’t any classy players on the 49ers squad, but since I’m a Rams fan, I just don’t like the 49ers, plain and simple. Even if the Niners win, it is great to think that the only team they couldn’t handle this year was the lowly St. Louis Rams!
There has been an interesting back-and-forth dialogue between former Rams star Marshall Faulk and several retired players from the New England Patriots over the past week. The issue at hand is the 2002 Super Bowl, or the mysterious ways in which the Patriots may or may not have taped the Rams walk-through practice before the game, and how that may or may not have given the Pats an advantage in their 20-17 victory that day. The Patriots have had many problems with videotapes over the years, so there will always be some suspicion as to what happened in 2002.
I’m interested in why we even need to have a discussion about 2002 eleven years later. When we look at the dynamics of remembering versus forgetting, wouldn’t this be something worth forgetting? It’s just a game, right?
I would argue that this game has been much more than that. It has had strong implications for the entire course of NFL history, as a matter of fact. For the Patriots, it was the beginning of a dynasty: five Super Bowl trips, three championships, and the emergence of perhaps the greatest quarterback in NFL history, Tom Brady. For the Rams, it was the beginning of a gradual decline into the league’s doghouse, something that has only begun to change over the past year. Our memory of the game and its consequences would be different if the two teams would have had different fates over the past decade. If the Rams would have remained an elite team, one that would have won at least one more championship, we probably wouldn’t remember 2002, or at least the cheating part. If the Patriots became a bad team, we probably wouldn’t have made such a fuss when it was discovered that they had been videotaping other teams in subsequent years, because it wouldn’t have worked. If both teams were good or if both were bad, 2002 wouldn’t matter, or at least as much as it seems matter to us today.
Faulk had this to say about that game:
Am I over the loss? Yeah, I’m over the loss. But I’ll never be over being cheated out of the Super Bowl. That’s a different story. I can understand losing a Super Bowl, that’s fine . . . But how things happened and what took place. Obviously, the commissioner gets to handle things how he wants to handle them but if they wanted us to shut up about what happened, show us the tapes. Don’t burn ’em.
Even though Faulk tried to focus on the Rams 2000 Super Bowl victory during this interview, the interviewer just had to ask Faulk about 2002, which was effective from a journalistic standpoint, because now people like me are talking about and linking you to his article.
Former Pats offensive lineman Matt Light had this to say in response to Faulk:
We lost two [Super Bowl] games horribly and I wouldn’t look at those games and say anything other than we missed our opportunity. We didn’t get it done. And it didn’t have anything to do with anyone else. Honestly to hear a comment like (Faulk’s), it’s disappointing to me, that a guy like Marshall — who has had such an incredible career and what he’s done post-football and all of the things that he stands for — would continue to go back to something like this. It shows a lot of disrespect from a guy that I’ve had a lot of respect for. And an organization that has done as much to promote this game, and this league, as anybody else. From that standpoint, it’s disappointing.“I understand what it’s like to lose a Super Bowl, and how you can have some ideas in your mind and other people can say things and you can get caught up in those. But ultimately when you look at it there’s no mistaking the dedication, the time, and all the effort that’s put into it by Bill Belichick and his staff and organization — what we did, we’re very proud of.
Former Linebacker Willie McGinest responded by saying “we were a smart football team… we didn’t make any excuses,” and that the Patriots weren’t “aware” of any cheating going on, whatever the hell that means.
What is stated by the former Patriots is equally interesting as what isn’t said. It seems to me that what they are arguing is for Faulk to get over it. We lost Super Bowls as well and we didn’t blame it on anyone else or make excuses for ourselves. We did a lot for the league and it’s disrespectful to even bring up this mystery of 2002. Be a man and get over yourself.
Under different circumstances, I would agree with Light and McGinest. Yet neither one of them came out and said “We didn’t cheat.” Light tries making a ridiculous argument about all the good the team did over the years in bringing fans to the league (ones that hated the Patriots and their cheating ways, I’m sure). McGinest says no one was “aware” of any cheating rather than saying that no one cheated, which seems like a cop-out. Neither one addresses the NFL’s actions in burning the confiscated tapes and neither one seems to understand that losing a game fair and square is one thing, but losing by the hands of cheaters is another. Perhaps the Pats didn’t cheat in the 2002 Super Bowl, but it is extremely disappointing that the tapes were burnt by the NFL when they concluded their “investigation.” It seems that if there was nothing to hide, then the tapes would have been made public, just like the Gregg Williams “Boutygate” tapes last year, and the Patriots organization would have been front and center, calling for the tapes to be publicized. Fifty years from now, historians of the NFL will never have the opportunity to fully understand what actually happened before that game thanks to these tapes being burned. It just goes to show that transparency is an important key to success and good relations with your cohorts, no matter the field. There is something to be said about forthrightness and honesty in a world that sometimes makes us question whether those qualities are still valued. Unfortunately, I don’t know if the Patriots, the greatest NFL team in the past 15 years, can be considered as such. I’m biased, but I know I’m not the only one who’s been thinking along these same lines.
Rant over. Until next time…